Top 10 Best Kayak Roof Racks In 2019 Reviews & Buying Guide

The top one percent get to spend their days in luxury, but even the wealthiest families have to choose between beaches, mountains, and rivers in their backyards. No one can have it all. That means we all have to find ways to transport our outdoor recreational equipment, such as kayaks, safely across the miles between our homes and those adventures we seek.

We have a list of the Best Kayak Roof Racks in the business right here for you. Also, we have put together a buyer’s guide to help you make the best choice for your kayak transporting needs.

kayak roof racks

Top 10 Best Kayak Roof Racks To Buy In 2019 Reviews


1 Thule 898 Hullavator Pro Kayak Lift System – The One-Man Brigade

Thule kayak roof rack is a good choice when finding the best one. Thule is one of the top manufacturers on the market today. Perhaps you may notice that they have three kayak racks and accessories on this list. Additionally, most of these kayak racks and accessories consistently rate at 4.5 stars or higher among reviewers.

The Hullavator is a unique accessory that allows one person to load kayaks of up to 75 lbs and 36 inches wide onto a roof rack. It fits all Thule rack systems and round bar systems. The gas struts it uses can hold up to 40 lbs themselves, making the lifting much easier for you. Also, There are “buckle bumpers,” which protect your car from scratches while the apparatus is in use.

Thule 898 Hullavator Pro Kayak Lift System - The One-Man Brigade
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros
  • Wider cradles can accommodate width hulls (up to 36 inches wide)
  • Waist-level loading, unloading and strapping
  • Gas struts making it easy to load and unload the kayak unassisted
  • Includes QuickDraw bow and stern tie downs
  • Includes two center straps with car-protective buckle bumpers
  • Fits Thule rack systems (excluding Thule Edge) and round bars
Cons
  • Sometimes has defective parts.

2 Yakima Jaylow Kayak Carrier – For the Infrequent Adventurer

The Yakima Jaylow is a suitable Kayak Carrier and one of the best kayak roof racks. It has an over-molded stainless steel strap. Also, it comes with a tool for easy torque set installation. You will find that there is plenty of room for other Yakima gear mounts with this carrier.

It is engineered for placement on vehicles that have raised siderails, and for most of these vehicles, you encounter little problems, especially with light use. That said, some customers who like to kayak regularly found that this carrier started to break down on them within the first year. The key seems to be lots of regular use over short periods of time wears the hardware down faster than usual.

Yakima Jaylow Kayak Carrier - For the Infrequent Adventurer
Our rating:4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)

Pros
  • Over-molded stainless steel strap
  • Risk-free torque set installation
  • Excellent roof clearance to allow a full range of Yakima gear mounts
  • RoundBar SL Adapter for StreamLine System Towers (sold separately)
  • Intended for mounting to vehicles with raised siderails
Cons
  • Low durability if used often

3 Thule Deckglide Kayak Saddle – One Size Fits All

Here is the kayak saddle that will compliment your Hullavator Pro from Thule, producer of some of the top kayak roof racks. This kayak saddle is designed to accommodate kayak’s up to 36 inches wide and up to 75 pounds.

Additionally, it is very adaptable to your needs. It works with all Thule rack systems, round bars, and most factory racks as well. This rackalso comes with special coverings for the buckles to keep your vehicle roof from getting scratched. Additionally, the saddle keeps the kayak secure with large cushioned pads.

The only downside to this saddle is that this protection comes with a cost, and that cost is not cheap.

Thule Deckglide Kayak Saddle - One Size Fits All
Our rating:4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)

Pros
  • Pivoting felt-lined rear saddles
  • Two independent pivoting saddles with angle-setting lever
  • Center load straps with car-protective buckle bumpers
  • Protects the hull with large, flexible, cushioned pads
  • Accommodates kayaks up to 36 inches wide and 75 lbs
  • Fits a variety of Thule rack systems, round bars, and most factory racks
Cons
  • Somewhat expensive
What kayak rack is recommended to be used with this?

4 Thule Hull-A-Port Xt Kayak Rack – The Rack For The Thule Kayak Kit

Thule has a full kayak system on the list of Best Kayak Roof Racks. They have a kayak lift. Also, there is a kayak saddle, to keep your kayak secure. However, this is the actual kayak rack itself. All of these parts can work together to provide you with the transportation you need for your kayak.

This rack is 10 inches wide and high, and it can carry up to two kayaks weighing up two 130 lbs combined. Additionally, it folds flat when not in use, and it has a universal car mounting design. It comes with straps, bumpers to protect your roof, and tie downs for one boat.

Some reviewers have had problems with the mounting being slightly unstable. This may be a design need corrected by use of the kayak saddle shown above.

Thule Hull-A-Port Xt Kayak Rack - The Rack for the Thule Kayak Kit
Our rating:4.2 out of 5 stars (4.2 / 5)

Pros
  • Made in the USA and Imported
  • 10″ high
  • 10″ wide
  • Carry up to two kayaks
  • Universal mounting design
  • Folds flat when not in use
  • Load straps with buckle bumpers and bow
  • Stern tie-downs included for one boat
  • Supports up to two boats with a combined weight of 130 lbs or less
  • Locks with Thule one key system lock cylinders (sold separately)
Cons
  • Mounting a bit unstable
What other brands made the best kayak roof racks list?

5 Malone Downloader – One Kayak Rack

Thule may provide three different utilities to transport your kayak. However, Malone gives you three-in-one with this kayak rack. This rack is meant to hold a single kayak, weighing up to 75 lbs.

The Malone Downloader is advertised as a universal fit. However, reviews show that it is not quite that adaptable. This rack fits a large number of vehicles, but it is not universal. Too many different vehicles come with too many different kinds of roofs.

The more significant trouble with this particular rack is that the durability does not quite match the cost of it. Often, companies will reduce the production cost significantly, in order to give customers a bit of saving. This usually ends up overcharging the customer for cheaper hardware. This may be part of the durability issues with this kayak rack. Even with this challenge though, the Downloader is one of the best kayak roof racks.

Malone Downloader - One Kayak Rack
Our rating:4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

Pros
  • J-style kayak carrier with built-in boarding ramp for easy loading
  • Fold down technology increases overhead clearance.
  • Compatible with the MPG351 Telos Load Assist
  • Oversized padding protects the boat during transport
  • JAWZ hardware fits round, square and most factory oval cross rails
  • Comes with both 60mm and 70mm pre-coated mounting bolts
  • Includes cam style load straps with buckle protectors
  • Dimensions:Length: 17″,Width: 6″,Height: 19.5″,
  • Load capacity: 75 lb
Cons
  • Not a universal fit
  • Durability does not always match the cost

6 Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal Car Rack – The Long Bolt Rack

Here is another style of rack by Malone, manufacturer of some of the top rated kayak roof racks. This is a saddle style car rack. Like the previous version, this is advertised as universal. However, reviewers are less vocal about the adaptability of this version for different kinds of vehicles.

The SeaWing rack is easy to mount and flexes to help improve your gas mileage. This too can only support one boat, but it can only hold up to 70 lbs. The biggest challenge this model faces, it shares with the Downloader: inferior hardware. For the SeaWing in particular, the trouble is bolts that are too long and threaten to dig into your vehicle roof. This is a great kayak rack, but you may need to purchase additional, shorter bolts to rig it up.

Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal Car Rack - The Long Bolt Rack
Our rating:4.3 out of 5 stars (4.3 / 5)

Pros
  • Low-profile kayak/cargo carrier with single saddle design
  • Easy-to-set-up mid-point mounting takes up minimal roof space
  • Flexes gently to cradle the boat and improve gas mileage
  • Jawz mounting hardware
  • Measures 27 x 5 x 6 inches (W x H x D); supports up to 70 pounds
Cons
  • Inferior hardware
  • Whistles on windy drives
  • May need to purchase shorter bolts
What about inflatable racks? Are they any good?

7 HandiRack – The Inflatable All-Purpose Rack

Inflatable racks are a different kind of equipment from regular kayak racks. Many of these are among top kayak roof racks because they are flexible and able to hold much more than just kayaks. The HandiRack is an excellent example of this.

It fits virtually any vehicle that has a hard-top and does not contain curtain airbags. No additional rails or gutters are required to mount this. It can carry anything that will fit on it and has room for expansion, holding up to 180 lbs. Also, it is certified for use up to highway speeds.

The challenge with this inflatable rack is that it cannot withstand high heat or pressure, and if you are not careful, it will scratch your car roof.

HandiRack - The Inflatable All-Purpose Rack
Our rating:3.9 out of 5 stars (3.9 / 5)

Pros
  • Inflatable rooftop car rack and expandable Cargo Carrier;
  • Carries luggage, camping gear, furniture & sports equipment like kayaks.
  • Multipurpose universal roof bars/roof rack
  • Fits: City car, Hatchback, Saloon, Estate, MPV, SUV, Crossover, 4×4
  • No side rails or gutters required;
  • Includes: 2 x HandiRack twin tubes, 2 x 3m tie-down HandiStraps
  • Also includes a HandiPump and a portable drawstring travel bag
  • Tested on all major vehicle brands
  • Textile Roof Bars
  • Lightweight & heavy-duty; Load capacity: 80kg (180lbs);
  • Certified for use up to Highway Speeds
Cons
  • Not suitable for automobiles with a soft-topor curtain airbags
  • Air chambers cannot take heat or pressure
  • Can scratch your car roof

8 ToughSteel® – The Twin Racks

This ToughSteel rack is actually two racks that work together to be one of the best kayak roof racks. Combined, they can hold up to 150 lbs. It has an easy installation. Also, it can be used for one kayak (2 racks) or 2 kayaks (4 racks).

Additionally, it will fit on square, round, oval, or blade cross bars. However, these racks work best on narrow roof rails. Wider roofs have problems fitting the ToughSteel racks. Reviewers have also noted that these racks could use some better straps.

ToughSteel® - The Twin Racks
Our rating:3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)

Pros
  • Made of 1.5mm thick Steel with Glossy Black Rust Free Paint
  • Easy Installation, professional pre-punched holes, perfect aligned
  • Universal Mount will fit on Square, Round, Oval or Blade Cross Bars,
  • Can hold up to 150 Lbs Kayak, Single or Double
  • Comes as 2 Pair, 4 Racks, Can hold up to 2 Kayaks
Cons
  • Only suited for narrow roof rails
  • Needs better straps
Are there any racks for sea kayaks?

9 The Kayak Wing – Sea Kayak Rack

The Kayak Wing is an all-in-one set that will hold your sea kayak on your vehicle. This roof rack is one of the best kayak roof racks for sea kayaks. The Kayak Wing is made for kayaks that are less than 30 inches wide. You will notice that this rack is lightweight. Yet it is also sturdy and reliable.

The reviewers really want to love this kayak rack, but the tightening knobs are hard to use. This, in turn, makes it challenging to get your kayak fully clamped down.

The Kayak Wing - Sea Kayak Rack
Our rating:3.6 out of 5 stars (3.6 / 5)

Pros
  • Sold as a Complete Set to Hold One Kayak, No Other Parts necessary
  • Best Suited for Boats under 30″ Wide
  • Sturdy, Reliable, and Lightweight
  • 5-year warranty against breakage
  • Made in the USA!
Cons
  • Difficult to get clamped down
  • Tightening knobs are hard to use
What is the best kayak roof rack for those on a budget?

10 TMS J-Bar Rack – Discount J-Bar Rack

If you want to transport your kayak but do not need a rack often enough to warrant spending lots of money on a rack, this may be one of the best kayak roof racks for you. It has a sturdy steel design with adjustable padding with quick on/off hardware.

The two challenges to this, similar to the Malone racks but more extreme, is that the hardware is of poor quality, so don’t expect exceptional durability with this rack. Additionally, it is a bit challenging to assemble. Once you get it on, you should be good to go, just be sure to be gentle with this rack.

As a special note, TMS has reported that authentic TMS hardware comes in vacuum-sealed packaging. This implies that there are fake TMS racks out there on the market, which may bring down the reviews of the hardware. Make sure your kayak rack is authentic.

TMS J-Bar Rack - Discount J-Bar Rack
Our rating:3.7 out of 5 stars (3.7 / 5)

Pros
  • Steel design with adjustable padding
  • Wide mouth J bar offers easier loading and unloading
  • Quick on/off hardware ensures fast installation and removal
  • Optimally sized J style carrier leaves roof space
  • Accommodates kayaks up to 36inch wide and 75lbs.
Cons
  • Assembly is a little challenging
  • Hardware is poor quality

Best Kayak Roof Racks Buyer’s Guide

Durability

The Thule Kayak racks and accessories are among the best kayak roof racks for the sake of durability. They consistently deliver safe travel from home, to the water, and back again. They are also some of the most expensive of the kayak racks. The Malone racks are not bad either. The most reviews about poor durability have been for the TMS rack and for the inflatable rack, both of which are far less expensive than the others.

best kayak roof racks

Ease of Use

The Thule racks again are easy to install and very easy to use, according to most reviews. That is perhaps the biggest reason they are on the best kayak roof racks list. The inflatable HandiRack was also rated as reasonably easy to use, even though it is a very different kind of rack setup. Where it had usage difficulty was driving through windy areas.

The most complaints about installation difficulty were for the TMS J-Bar Rack. It comes with all the parts necessary, but several reviewers claim that it is a bit complicated to assemble.

Safe For Vehicle

One of the common problems of any of the best kayak roof racks is that it can scratch the roof of your vehicle when loaded down with your boat. What should you look for to prevent this? Buckle Bumpers.

The Thule kayak racks all come with buckle bumpers, which prevent the metal buckles from touching the roof of your vehicle. These preventative measures help ensure that your car, truck, or SUV is not damaged.

The second important thing to look for in-vehicle safety is straps that tie the boat down tightly. One reviewer complained that her kayak came loose and fell over the side of her vehicle, smashing in the side of her car. The Kayak Wing, the TMS, and the ToughSteel all had different issues in getting the kayak secured in place.

Conclusion

The Thule, Malone, and Yakima kayak roof racks are the best kayak roof racks for all of the categories in general, and the Thule racks are probably the highest rated as a whole. They are also the most expensive. If you want to have a quality, durable kayak roof rack, you are going to have to spend some money on it. If you go with a cheaper model, you are taking a chance of losing your kayak or damaging your vehicle.

Top 10 Best Kayak Roof Racks In 2019 Reviews & Buying Guide
5 (100%) 63 votes